Sometimes I think about all the choices that led us to where we are, all the little things that had to happen to bring us together. I think about the first night we talked at the bar. How I just happened to leave the party I was at. How you just happened to be out celebrating getting into graduate school with your roommates. How we just happened to be at the bar at the same time. Even though I had my fair share of tequila that night, I remember seeing you and thinking "this is my opportunity and I'm gonna take it." I let you know I was interested and foisted my phone number upon you. And you found me on facebook and we planned a meeting.
Beyond that I think about choosing to spend my summer with you instead of study for prelims. I think about keeping in touch with you once you moved to NC, even though my heart broke every day that you were away, and talking to you only made me more acutely aware of how hard I had fallen for you. I think about after I visited you there, then when we stopped speaking. I remember getting Melinda to message you when she and I were drinking together one night, and you told her "this isn't easy for me either, I lost my best friend." I knew after hearing that I couldn't let you go, that eventually I had to start talking to you again. I think about how hard it was not speaking to you, and then how hard and awkward those first few weeks were when we started talking again.
I think about NYE 2010/2011 and making the decision to spend it with you after my plans all fell through. I probably could have stayed in Binghamton and found something to do, but I didn't want to be alone or surrounded by couples. I wanted to be with you. Imagine if my plans hadn't been canceled. I'd have never met your grandparents that weekend, or your high school friends.
I wonder what would have happened if one of us had decided to give up on the other. I don't think either of us ever really have, not before this. I have always known how I feel about you and what spending time with you means to me. Even after you moved to NC and even after I visited, I didn't want to let you go. And through it all I don't think you ever really wanted to let me go either. I'm slowly starting to realize that I have meant something more to you than I ever imagined, and how badly I have hurt you. Even though you don't really explicitly state your feelings, I've come to realize that you show me how much you cared by being patient with me and listening to me and being supportive when I'm stressed.
I think there have been so many chances for either of us to just throw in the towel, and now we've come to the place where it might happen...
This past weekend, I told you that I've been lying to you for the last four months, withholding information that I should have come forward with at the outset. I caused you unnecessary grief. I pretended to be innocent when I actually did something very similar to what you'd done, to what I've thrown in your face for the past few months.
I understand that this has shaken your trust in me to the very foundation, perhaps irreconcilably. After I initially didn't tell you, I've been wresteling with the decision to come forward since the first week in April. I knew there would be huge consequences because I waited to say something, and I knew every day that went by made it worse.
I didn't tell you this because I expected you'd be okay with it, or because I thought it would be easy or because I couldn't live with it anymore. I told you because you deserved to know. I knew telling you would make things worse for a long time, if not end them completely. I told you this because I want to move forward with you without anything between us. I know if you decide to move forward with me, it will take you a while to get to where I'm at. Because I'm done with bad feelings between us. Last week felt different. It felt like we'd finally gotten to a really good place. You opened up to me and set straight some of my misconceptions and I was able to be emotional without fearing any consequences. I finally felt a peace between the two of us, like it was how it was supposed to be, without any anger or jealousy or bad feelings about the past. Except in my heart I knew that I had done wrong by you and you didn't deserve it. More than that, you deserved to know that I am a hypocrite.
I could have waited to tell you until after Lake George. I could have ensured that we had a really great trip together, potentially a last trip, and then told you. That would have been even more unfair to you and more selfish on my part. I realize that I am uninvited, and I brought it upon myself. I'd rather have the truth out than have continued to lie to you for another two weeks. I accept the consequences.
You told me that when you forgive someone, you let it go. You don't bring it up and continue to make them feel bad about it, because that doesn't mean it's forgiven. You're right. I hadn't forgiven you about what happened this spring. I continued to bring it up, even though I had done something similar. I was ruled by my emotions and I was terrified of what you'd say when you found out what I had done. More than that, I was terrified that I would lose you. I have a long way to go and a lot to learn about life and people and situations and myself and my insecurites. I am learning from this, though. In the silence between us, I have thought about a lot of things, learned a lot about myself.
What I did wasn't fair. You had a right to know that information and I hid it. Beyond that, I acted like I was innocent when I wasn't. As a result you beat yourself up about something that wasn't very different from what I had done myself. I let you feel bad about it for four months. You say you're the messed up one, that you don't feel things the way normal people do, but I'm messed up in my own way. I was scared and hurt and emotional. I didn't stop to think about your feelings long enough. I tried to protect myself at the expense of hurting you. I have no excuses for what I did, because to put it as simply as possible, it was just wrong.
I was afraid that you'd shut down and push me away if I told you I'd been with someone else. And by waiting to tell you and acting as though I was innocent, I did something worse. It seems as though I've done exactly what I was afraid of doing.
Can you find it in your heart to forgive me or give me another chance to show you who I really am? I messed up really bad, and I know that. I'm a human and I make mistakes and I made a really big one. But I'm asking for a chance to make it up to you, a chance to show you that I am better than what I've done, that it is not representative of who I am as a whole, but instead it's a mistake that I made. I truly didn't do this with the intention of hurting you...
And I am sick inside at the thought that you have been hurting more than I ever imagined over the past 4 months... sick at the thought that you hurt yourself because of your guilt and your pain about what you had done. I didn't do what I should have to diminish that guilt and pain, and instead made you feel worse for your actions when I knew there were things I hadn't told you that were essentially the same as the things you felt bad about. There's no way for me to take that back. There's no way for me to take back every offhand remark I ever made about what you did, there's no way for me to take back the times I made you feel guilty by talking about what happened and how it made me feel. I can't undo what's been done. Maybe that's something I have to live with for the rest of my life, knowing that I hurt you and that you can't forgive me for it. And I will accept that if that's what you decide. But I will continue to hope that you can find it in your heart to give me a second chance. Please give me a second chance...
I don't expect you to believe me when I tell you that I am done bringing up things that happened in the past between us. And I don't expect that you'll believe me when I say that I'm sorry. Why would you? People often make promises that are just empty words. All I have to give you is time and space to think about this. Beyond that, I hope that one day I can show you through my actions that I mean what I say, that I don't say it lightly or without the intention of following through on my words. That I am truly sorry for what I've done, that I understand how badly I've hurt you, and that I mean it when I say I want to be in the present with you, not living in past mistakes. I'm not asking to be forgiven today, or tomorrow, or any time soon, because what I did may be unforgivable... but I'm asking for a second chance to show you that I am more than the sum of my errors, that you mean more to me than
how I treated you. To show you that I have behaved like a hypocrite, but I am not a bad person.
I kept a secret out of selfishness, fear, and a desire to protect myself. I believed I was protecting you, too. I was completely wrong in my actions. But I confessed my mistakes from a good place, the place in me that knows you deserve to know everything, the place in me that knew you deserved better than what I had done.
If we can somehow move beyond this, I know it's not gonna be easy. It's gonna be really hard. We're gonna have to work at this every day, but I want to do that because I want you. I want all of you, always, you and me, every day. Do something for me, please? Picture your life for me. 1 year from now. 5 years from now. 10 years from now. What does it look like? If I'm not in it, let me know. I've thought I lost you before, I thought there was no hope of more... I think I can do again, if I thought that's what you really wanted. Don't think about what I want, just think about what you want. What do you want?
I know that I will never be perfect. This isn't the last time I will make a mistake. This isn't the last time I'll ask you to forgive me. But I can learn from my mistakes, and I can grow. You'll make mistakes, too, and it'll be up to me whether to forgive you or not. But I believe that I would forgive you, again and again, always, because you are what I want as a whole. I've seen what you've shown me of your lowest, your worst, and in the end all I have to say is "it's okay, I know all of you, and I accept all of you, and I want all of you, mistakes and all." If this has made you reconsider my worth as a person, has made you believe that I'm not a person you want in your life, that saddens me. I'm sorry I did something to hurt you so badly that what we had might end. That is something I will always carry with me.
I know you might not believe that I understand what I did, but in the silence between us I've had time to reconsider things I'd forgotten, and I believe I've had more than a few revelations in the past four days...
I believe that because of what your first ex did to you, you are less able to trust women and you hold your emotions back (if not stop them dead in their tracks). You got into anothing relationship in college, but you felt less whole because of the damage your first girlfriend had done and as a result you were less able to fully engage in the second relationship. Then that relationship ended last year, and I believe you were hurt more than you admit because it didn't work out, regardless of whether you feel that it ending was a good thing or not. You found it hard to be emotionally open and available because you have a hard time trusting others after what has happened to you and after what you've seen happen to others.
And then you did something that you felt was similar to what your ex did. Even though we weren't involved, you knew I had feelings for you and you hid your relationship this past spring from me. Further than that, you cared deeply about me, more than I ever realized. When you told me about it, I believe you felt as though you were an awful person because you had done something along a continuum of what had been done to you. I want you to know that's not how I thought of it, but I believe that to a degreen you felt as though you had done something non-representative of you as a person, something you are cautious to never do. You felt awful inside at the thought that you might have hurt me the way you had been hurt in the past. You felt pain and overwhelming guilt that you had lied to me, and you felt like you were no better than the people who had caused you to lose trust and faith in relationships.
You worried that I would lose trust and faith in you and in a relationship, and every time I brought up what had happened you felt like it was confirmation that you were a bad person, that you had irreparably hurt me, and you felt like I hadn't forgiven you when I continued to bring it up because what you had done was that awful.
In reality, I had lied to you about my actions as well. Even though I told you I was dating other people, I never let on how far I had gone, and instead told you that I was not seriously involved with anyone. When you finally confessed about your relationship, instead of saying that I had also been hiding something, I asked you if you wanted to know what I had done. Then I rationalized that you said you didn't want to know so it was best left unsaid...
The fact that you slept with someone never upset me that much. Similarly to what you told me on Sunday, I easily forgave you the act, but the covering it up was what bothered me. But it didn't end there because I continued to hide information from you. You interpreted any time I alluded to what had happened as me trying to tell you that you were a horrible person, that you had mutilated my trust in you beyond recognition. After the first few days that you were open with me about the what happened, I thought that that you had moved on and wanted to leave it in the past. In truth, you were trying to move on, but you still felt horribly guilty. You thought that you deserved to feel guilty, and you didn't want to share it with me because you figured I thought you deserved it, too. Why else would I keep bringing it up?
Initially, I felt that I couldn't tell you what I'd done because you'd be disgusted with me, you'd be disgusted that I slept with someone I hadn't been dating for very long. We'd had talks about how many people we'd slept with, and I knew that you thought my number was on the high side. I thought if I told you what I'd done, you'd see me differently. I thought you were never really that sure about how much you liked me in the first place so that giving you more information would just tip you over the edge and you'd be done with me. I realize those are my own insecurities and if I ever hope to move forward with you, I have to own them and trust that if you want to be with me, you will. I slept with someone because I wanted to feel that someone wanted me, because I was lonely. Then I was angry at you when you told me you wanted to try more. I had been willing to try more from the very beginning, and I thought it would ruin this chance if I told you that I had slept with someone. I thought I had messed it up before it even began. So instead of coming clean, I asked you if there was anything you wanted to know, and when you told me there wasn't I hid what I had done.
As a few days went on, I realized my trust in you had been shaken. Even though I knew I wanted to move forward with you I also knew that I needed time to trust you again. I didn't tell you what I had done then because I believed your trust in me would be shaken, too. I knew how I felt about what you had done, and I figured you would feel the same way towards me. I always believed that I had stronger feelings for you than you ever did for me. If it was hard for me to see past what you had done, I figured it would be impossible for you to see past what I had done, because I thought you were never sure you wanted a relationship with me to begin with. I heard you saying you had all these reasons and reservations about getting in a relationship, and I made that about me, and I was terrified of adding another reason to that list of reasons we couldn't be together, so I covered up what I had done.
And then more time went on, and I didn't tell you because I knew I had made a mistake in not telling you, and I knew that it would wreck what we were working towards, and I was terrified of losing you. But I'd rather have you know what I've done than be with me while thinking that I've never messed up. In the end, covering it up didn't help anything and instead it may have completely destroyed my closest friendship and the only relationship I ever truly believed might turning into something lasting and meaningful.
I've meant everything I've ever told you about how much you mean to me and how happy you make me. I have never met someone like you before, someone I could see myself willingly making compromises for, someone I wanted to grow with and learn from. Someone I didn't want to change. Someone who made me better, who enriched my life every day. Even through the tough times, you have been my closest confidant this past year, the person I tell all of my fears, hopes, and dreams. This is the only thing I've ever hidden from you, and I didn't do it out of maliciousness towards you. I did it because I have some issues that I hadn't worked out. You never deserved this. I'm working on my issues though, and I'm learning and I'm trying to make things right.
I truly believe if I had stopped to think about how you might be feeling, if I had considered everything I knew about you and your past, and truly examined what it must have felt like for you to tell me about Carrie, I would have confessed what I had done at the same time. If I had any clue about the guilt
that you would feel... If I actually believed that you cared about me and wanted to make something work between us, instead of mistrusting you because you didn't want to immediately jump into something... I would have done things differently. I know I messed up really badly. I acted as though I had done nothing wrong, that I was the victim, and that you had done wrong by me. Beyond that, I should never have continued to bring it up after I said I forgave you. I should have told you what I did. I was afraid and I was hurt and I justified my actions to myself because I didn't trust that you cared about me. I let my judgment come from a place of insecurity that has existed since long before you ever knew me. Those are my issues and I own them. Though things that have happened between us may have caused me to question your feelings for me, it is no excuse for how I treated you...
Somewhere along the line I forgot that you are sensitive and soft inside, that your behavior masks what you're feeling, that you don't share everything with me, especially not the most vulnerable parts of yourself. I started to resent you for the unrequited feelings I had in the past, and the pain that I was caused because you didn't want a relationship with me on my timeline. I saw you as distant and unyielding, when you are so much more than that, more underneath all of that. Being away from you made me only hear your words, and I lost touch with all of your actions, with how much you listen and care and play and laugh. With how in touch with me you are, and how underneath your exterior there lives a person who has been hurt very badly in the past, almost to the edge of doing something irreparable. I took that person for granted... I forgot who you really are, I forgot to be vigilant and I forgot to stop and think about what you mean behind you say. I started to resent you for wanting to do things your way... I messed up so badly... I will do my best to never forget again.
It makes me sad thinking that this might be the end, that we might never see our full potential because I made a huge mistake... You can ignore me, try to pretend that I don't exist, but somewhere I feel like it wasn't supposed to end like this and I can only hope that you feel that way too... hope you know all of me, know my flaws and my weaknesses, but also know that I am not a one dimensional person. I messed up, but I think I do a lot right, too. I hope you can see the good in me... please know me better than only seeing my mistakes. I can be a mess. I am overemotional, and impatient, and I make mistakes. But I also care about you with my whole heart, I think of you and I try to be supportive of you, and I try to be there for you in whatever way I can. I'm still the same girl you've called your best friend for the past several months, I just made a really big mistake.
I still want you in my life. I always will. Your flaws and your bullheadedness and how different you are from me are all parts of who you are as a whole. I want all of it in my life, because I want all of you, the good and the bad and the in-between.
I know things won't be the same, not for a long time if ever. I'd like to hope that this can somehow help both of us grow stronger together, but instead I think it may have destroyed our friendship... and that if we are friends again in the future, you will never think of me the same way.
I know it would be easy to hate me and it will be hard to move on... There will be dark places in any relationship, and we've entered into one. Please let us weather this storm.
I miss my best friend and I'm sorry I hurt him.
No comments:
Post a Comment